Shield Nickel

Auction and Coin Market Price guide

Shield nickels were produced during the Civil War, and like the three cent nickel and three cent silver, Shield nickels were the government's response to the hoarding of coins. These coins were composed of 75% copper and 25% nickel, and featured a shield on the front and the Roman numeral five surrounded by stars on the back. The shield nickel was the first ever five-cent coin minted in the United States, and was also the first nickel with a face value of five cents. Due to nickel being an extremely hard metal, many of these coins have flaws.

Shield Nickel Statistics
Issue Dates1866-1883
DesignerJames B. Longacre
Diameter20.50 mm/0.81 inch
Weight5.00 grams/0.16 ounce
Composition75% copper, 25% nickel
EdgePlain
Mint markNone
MintageN/A
Source Count $ Value
 
Auction  
PCGS195$74,341
NGC152$75,661
ANACS72$9,584
ICG7$0,736
Subtotal426$160,323
Buy It Now
PCGS38$22,632
NGC14$11,374
ANACS8$0,934
ICG2$0,325
Subtotal62$35,264
Total488$195,587
Open Auctions
Current:$450.00
Bid:5
Ends:4:36 PM
Current:$328.35
Bid:7
Ends:5:0 PM
Current:$92.50
Bid:5
Ends:9:9 PM
Current:$0.99
Bid:1
Ends:8:18 PM
Current:$137.50
Bid:13
Ends:11:34 PM
Current:$0.99
Bid:1
Ends:7:37 PM
Shield Nickel Market Prices
Attribute Value
Gray first market price for this item
Green last market price greater than previous
Red last market price less than previous
Shield Five CentEF40EF45AU50AU55AU58MS61MS62MS63MS64MS65
Click coin name to view auction.  
1866 P PCGS $120.01 PCGS $159.00 PCGS $245.00 PCGS $239.00 PCGS $275.00 PCGS $490.00 PCGS $359.00 PCGS $490.00 PCGS $687.77 NGC $1525.00
1867 P PCGS $91.00 PCGS $51.00 ANACS $76.00 PCGS $120.00 PCGS $382.77 NGC $280.09 PCGS $187.50 PCGS $460.50 PCGS $754.00 NGC $621.00
1867 P OGH - - - - - - - PCGS $189.99 - -
1868 P ICG $36.20 PCGS $54.00 ANACS $89.88 PCGS $100.00 NGC $81.01 - PCGS $134.28 PCGS $420.00 - -
1868 P NGC* - - - - - - - - - NGC $480.00
1869 P PCGS $49.00 - ANACS $83.00 ICG $94.99 - ANACS $141.49 PCGS $1420.00 PCGS $193.50 - NGC $495.00
1869 P BU - - - - - - - - - NGC $249.00
1869 P SP - - - - - - - - - NGC $399.99
1870 P - ANACS $15.49 PCGS $92.77 - ANACS $105.00 - - - - -
1871 P - - ANACS $280.00 - - - - NGC $516.00 - -
1872 P - PCGS $133.38 - ANACS $110.00 PCGS $199.00 - NGC $172.50 PCGS $285.00 - -
1873 P ANACS $52.33 - - NGC $154.50 - - ANACS $231.38 - - -
1873 P Closed 3 - PCGS $155.95 - - ANACS $103.50 - NGC $227.50 - NGC $430.00 -
1873 P Open 3 - - - - - - NGC $190.00 - - -
1874 P - - - PCGS $151.11 NGC $135.00 - - - ANACS $427.00 -
1875 P - - - PCGS $154.49 - - - - - -
1876 P - - - PCGS $152.50 - NGC $187.51 NGC $203.50 NGC $392.00 NGC $325.00 PCGS $1300.00
1879 P - - PCGS $1087.88 - - - - - - -
1881 P - - ANACS $300.78 - - PCGS $832.45 NGC $910.00 - - -
1882 P PCGS $49.00 - ANACS $79.99 PCGS $98.00 PCGS $105.50 ANACS $103.59 PCGS $146.56 PCGS $285.00 PCGS $280.00 PCGS $685.00
1882 P PL - - - - - PCGS $225.00 - - - -
1882 P UC - - - - - - - - - PCGS $423.10
1883 P PCGS $65.00 PCGS $53.44 PCGS $90.00 PCGS $70.70 PCGS $90.00 NGC $127.00 PCGS $160.00 PCGS $190.00 PCGS $257.00 PCGS $189.00
1883 P 1883/2 - - PCGS $120.00 - - - - NGC $127.50 PCGS $242.51 -
1883 P OGH - - - - PCGS $91.99 - PCGS $133.50 - - -